Review #1: Poison the Well - You Come Before You

artist: poison the well album: you come before you label: atlantic records released: 7/1/03 by: eduardo moutinho There is a disturbing trend going around our underground music scene. This trend concerns the actions of major record labels doing their best to come and pluck away some of the most well-known and popular bands from the rose that is our scene. Many bands have fallen under the spell of the money-grubbing majors, such as Thursday, Glassjaw, and the authors of the record that is being reviewed in this very text: Poison the Well. Fortunately, for the most part, the sound that made these bands famous is not being compromised. Glassjaw’s Warner Brothers debut, Worship and Tribute, was an absolute hurricane of greatness. And from the looks of it, Thursday’s next record will follow suit. And folks, I’m happy to say, that Poison the Well’s debut on Atlantic, You Come before You, is quite splendid. Poison the Well’s previous release, Tear from the Red, on Trustkill Records was met with mixed reviews. The group took its sound in a new direction, focusing more on heavy, crunchy, melodies and incorporating more singing into the music. Many were annoyed by this, instead wanting another The Opposite of December, the band’s most famous and influential record. I enjoyed Tear from the Red quite a bit but found myself always going back to Opposite of December, because of the epic nature of that record. In fact, I was fearful that the band would continue to change their sound, since they were releasing a debut record on a major. I was hoping that I would not have to prematurely start talking about the “good ol’ days when Poison the Well was a pioneer in melodic hardcore.” In the end, I didn’t want to hear You Come before You and hear a slightly edgy hard rock band. Thankfully, from hearing this record, I realized that the guys were given the freedom necessary to craft a record to their own specifications. You Come before You is in essence, a culmination of Poison the Well’s musical evolution. There’s a little Opposite of December here, and a little Tear from the Red there, even some Distance Only Makes the Heart Grow Fonder hidden behind a couple of layers. This, in my opinion, is the most notable strength of this record. The chaos and rawness is back, yet the increased use of singing and melody remains. There are songs that are pure aggression and emotion, that have very few breaks, and then there are songs that have slow parts accompanied by heart-felt singing. And of course, there are songs that combine everything into a big ball of melodicore. I must say, that with the evolution of Poison the Well’s sound has come an evolution of musicianship by the band members. The guitars are great here, and I can already imagine Ryan Primack playing this stuff live with his facial expressions. I can’t wait. There are sweet little riffs here and there. Just listen to “Zombies are Good for your Health” to see what I mean. These guys still concentrate on the heavy rhythm, and they execute with great efficiency. Drums are always a highlight of Poison the Well’s music, and on this record, the high marks continue. Expect to see well-placed fills, great snare work, and overall goodness. And the vocals are the same, as Jeff Moreira is in my opinion, the best vocalist in hardcore. This guy has a spectacular screaming voice, and a singing voice that would get him far on American Idol. On this album, he changes his screaming style just a bit, which adds so much to the sound. He ends and starts screams, on many occasions, by transitioning from his regular voice to the scream, which sounds really crisp and hits my ear just right. Also, his screams aren’t as high-pitched as they used to be, which is also good. Definitely, Jeff’s vocals are fantastic here. Songs like “Loved Ones,” the aforementioned “Zombies are Good for your Health,” and the end track “Crystal Lake” (which sounds a bit too much like “Zombies…”) are frenzied and filled with speed and heat. “Loved Ones” in particular is spectacular, where fast-paced heavy verses are intertwined with moody, atmospheric interludes with singing. Then, there are songs like “Meeting Again for the First Time” and “The View from Here is a Brick Wall” that are reminiscent of Tear from the Red tracks, with slow introductions and roller coaster-like song structures. The guitarists in particular, really want to show that they are getting better and better, so many of the songs have a lot of atmosphere and complicated effect-driven clean parts thrown into them. The song “Sounds Like the End of the World” is the heaviest atmospheric song I have ever heard, and that makes it really interesting. I also like how the band chose to add more traditional-sounding songs, with lots of tempo, heaviness, and little to no singing in them, to keep the variety in good check. There are instances where the “hard part to slow singing part to hard part” structure wears a bit thin. Fortunately, this problem is remedied a bit by songs like “For a Bandaged Iris” and “The Realist” that sound like nothing that Poison the Well has done before. The songs have a lot of high trebly parts matched up with heavy accompaniments, and even more uncharacteristic song structures. And to be quite honest, I think these songs will hit the Poison the Well faithful in a more positive manner than the Tear from the Red ones. Overall, I’m really pleased with this record. It’s hard to say that this is my favorite Poison the Well release, but I can say that I find it to be a lot better than Tear from the Red and easily in the league of Opposite of December. There are all sorts of songs here, really hard ones, all-over-the-place tracks, and even experimental pieces. Thankfully, the suits didn’t intervene and force this band into becoming another Hatebreed or Shadows Fall. favorite song: “loved ones” rating: 93%/100% listen to poison the well